Pizza · The Gainesville slice
Pizza in Gainesville
The Gainesville pizza answer is Atlas Pizza on the downtown square, the hand-tossed house at 104 Washington, with Roma New York Pizzeria holding the Riverside Drive room that used to be City Park Pizza. Three more verified rooms round out the city's list.
Gainesville is the biggest city on this side of the lake, and its pizza map runs from the square to the riverfront. The national names sit on the same highways; these are the rooms worth driving to, all verified by name and address.
The square and the riverfront
Downtown Gainesville's pizza
Atlas Pizza
The hand-tossed house on the square, a real downtown pizzeria with the walk-up trade that fills the block after courthouse hours.
Roma New York Pizzeria
New York-style pies in the Riverside Drive room that City Park Pizza built and left, under new owners. The riverfront answer.
Around the city
The rest of the verified list
Johnny's New York Style Pizza
The corridor's New York-style mini-chain at its Gainesville stop, big slices near the parkway.
Vendetti's Pizza Pasta Grill
A pizza-and-pasta grill on the High Street side, the sit-down option west of the square.
Napoli's Pizza
The Mundy Mill room of the Napoli's kitchen, the dependable call for the south side toward Oakwood.
Pizza Hut and Papa Johns sit on Browns Bridge and Jesse Jewell, Domino's and Little Caesars on the highway strips, and Stevi B's runs its buffet on Browns Bridge Road. The full Gainesville dining picture is on the Gainesville restaurants page.
An editorial guide, not a listings site. Updated September 22, 2026. Real-estate guidance on this page is provided by Rob Dietrich, REALTOR® with eXp Realty, LLC.