Pizza · The Sugar Hill slice
Pizza in Sugar Hill
The Sugar Hill pizza answer is short, and it is Shine Pizza on West Broad, the local room that took over the strip's old Knuckies space. For delivery and pickup, the national names cover the rest of the city.
Sugar Hill has never been a pizza-heavy city, so this page stays honest and short: one verified local room, then the delivery options. Nothing here is padded, and nothing is invented.
The local room
Shine Pizza, on West Broad
Shine Pizza
5019 W Broad St NE, Suite M115 · (678) 765-7627
The local pizza room on the West Broad strip, pies and slices in the space where Knuckies Pizza and Hoagies used to run. It is the one verified in-city pizzeria, and it is the answer for a Sugar Hill pizza night.
The delivery names
When nobody cooks
Papa Johns Pizza
1498B Buford Hwy NE
The pickup-and-delivery name on the Buford Highway edge of the city.
Pizza Hut
5885 Cumming Hwy NE
The Cumming Highway room on the lake side of Sugar Hill.
Marco's Pizza
5965 Cumming Hwy NE
Another reliable delivery kitchen on the Cumming Highway strip.
The full Sugar Hill dining picture is on the Sugar Hill restaurants page; the bigger pizza maps sit a short drive south in Buford and Suwanee.
An editorial guide, not a listings site. Updated September 13, 2026. Real-estate guidance on this page is provided by Rob Dietrich, REALTOR® with eXp Realty, LLC.